Which Hakone Ryokan Will Steal Your Heart in 2025? Discover the Ultimate Guest Experiences!

Konnichiwa! 🎎

Welcome to Moshi Moshi Travel Japan, your one-stop newsletter for discovering Japan's hidden gems and beauty. Our newsletter includes travel itineraries and tips for your upcoming and future trips to Japan. If you have any specific topics you'd like us to cover, questions, or need consultations about your travel to Japan, please contact us at [email protected].

• Please support our sponsor and partners. They provide valuable information for you and me.

• If you enjoy this newsletter, please consider sharing it with your friends and family by clicking the button below. ⬇️

Are you looking to escape the hustle and bustle of Tokyo and find tranquility in Hakone? Our guide to the best ryokans is here to help! We’ve gathered guest reviews and insider tips on a variety of stays, from traditional inns to luxurious options. Whether you want to enjoy an onsen experience or indulge in kaiseki dining, our newsletter will highlight the top ryokans in Hakone. Subscribe now for exclusive insights and make your Hakone getaway truly magical!

Links We Like

Discovering the Best of Hakone: A Personal Guide to Ryokans and Real Guest Experiences

Hakone, just a short 90-minute journey from the bustling streets of Tokyo, offers a beautiful and peaceful escape into nature. Known for its hot springs (onsen), stunning views of Mount Fuji, and rich cultural heritage, it’s no wonder that Hakone has become a beloved destination for those seeking a bit of relaxation and indulgence. One of the highlights of staying in Hakone is choosing a ryokan—a traditional Japanese inn where you can enjoy personalized service, traditional tatami rooms, kaiseki meals, and of course, soothing onsen baths. But as with any travel decision, not all ryokans are created equal. The quality of your experience can vary, and that’s something we’ve come to realize after reviewing feedback from real guests and taking a closer look at some of the top ryokans in the area.

We’re sharing our thoughts and recommendations to help you navigate your own Hakone ryokan journey, so you know exactly what to expect when you book your stay. From glowing Google reviews to Reddit posts that raise some interesting concerns, we’ve gathered the real scoop from visitors just like you.

Yama no Chaya: A Divided Experience

One ryokan that’s come up frequently in our discussions is Yama no Chaya. You’ve probably read rave reviews about it, as many visitors seem to absolutely love the experience here. The picturesque setting, private onsen baths, and multi-course meals seem to capture the essence of a perfect Hakone getaway. But as we dug deeper, we came across a Reddit post that painted a very different picture. One guest who stayed in November 2024 shared their disappointing experience, which we thought was important to highlight for potential visitors.

The guest paid about ¥120,442 (roughly $793) for one night in the Nadeshiko room. For that price, they expected an exceptional stay, but unfortunately, they found themselves let down by several aspects of their experience. The most glaring issue? The kaiseki dinner, which, according to the guest, was far below expectations. They mentioned that the sashimi was rubbery, some dishes were too salty, while others lacked flavor entirely. The guest was very familiar with Japanese cuisine and noted that the food quality just didn’t meet the high standards one would expect from a high-end ryokan.

But food was only part of the issue. The service was another sore spot. The room attendant seemed rushed, and there was a general lack of attention to detail during the stay. The check-in process was impersonal, feeling more like a routine script than the warm welcome you might expect from a ryokan. To make matters worse, when the guest raised concerns about the meal, they didn’t receive the attentive response they hoped for. The manager wasn’t available to address the issue, and the owner’s response the next day was defensive, offering no real resolution.

On top of the service and food, the physical facilities also had some drawbacks. While the private onsen in their room was a nice touch, the view was less than ideal, overlooking a parking lot and construction site. While this may not be a dealbreaker for everyone, it’s worth considering, especially if a tranquil, scenic view is part of what you’re looking for during your stay.

So, what’s the takeaway from this? Yama no Chaya clearly has its fans, but based on this particular review, it’s important to go in with realistic expectations. The food, service, and facilities may not be as perfect as the other glowing reviews would suggest, so if these aspects are crucial for your stay, you might want to consider other options.

A Different Perspective: Google Reviews Show More Positives

Interestingly, Google reviews for Yama no Chaya present a very different picture. Many guests have left glowing reviews, praising everything from the beauty of the ryokan to the friendly staff. One reviewer who stayed there for a friend’s birthday described the ryokan as “absolutely gorgeous,” noting the stunning views and the attentive service. The kaiseki meals were visually appealing, and while some guests mentioned the heavy fish content, they still found the meals enjoyable—especially for those who appreciate seafood.

Another guest had a fantastic two-night stay in late April, highlighting the warm hospitality of the staff and the private onsen with a beautiful view. In fact, this guest mentioned how their assigned attendant went above and beyond, making their stay feel truly special. It’s clear that for many visitors, Yama no Chaya delivers an exceptional experience, especially when it comes to the aesthetic beauty and the peaceful ambiance.

So what do we make of this? Well, it’s pretty clear that experiences can vary depending on timing, expectations, and personal preferences. If you're someone who enjoys a peaceful, beautiful setting and you’re not too concerned about the food or occasional service hiccups, Yama no Chaya could still be a great choice. But, as with any travel decision, it’s crucial to consider both the glowing reviews and the more critical ones before making your decision.

Our Thoughts on Hakone’s Best Ryokans

After looking at the reviews and reflecting on what we’ve seen in Hakone, there are definitely some ryokans that consistently come out on top. If you’re looking for an experience that ticks all the boxes—great food, exceptional service, and tranquil settings—there are several places we would recommend. Let’s dive into a few of our top picks:

1. Hakone Yumoto Onsen Tenseien

If you're after a ryokan that combines traditional and modern elements seamlessly, Tenseien is a fantastic choice. Nestled in the heart of Hakone, Tenseien offers stunning open-air baths with therapeutic hot spring waters, as well as a beautiful garden that features a shrine and a footbath. Guests rave about the buffet-style dinners, which offer a mix of Japanese and Western dishes—something for everyone. It’s a place that delivers the best of both worlds: a serene retreat with all the comforts of modern amenities.

2. Onsen Ryokan Ichinoyu Honkan

For those seeking a more authentic and serene atmosphere, Ichinoyu Honkan is a fantastic choice. The ryokan features traditional tatami rooms and elegant minimalist decor that transports you into a more tranquil time. The communal and private baths are an added bonus, and the experience feels authentically Japanese. If you’re not looking for flashy amenities but rather a true Japanese getaway, Ichinoyu Honkan is the place to go.

3. Hakone Pax Yoshino

Looking for a mix of luxury and traditional charm? Hakone Pax Yoshino offers rooms with stunning river views, many of which come with private open-air baths. Guests rave about the kaiseki meals prepared with seasonal, locally sourced ingredients, as well as the exquisite design of the ryokan. If you're after top-notch cuisine and a memorable dining experience in a tranquil environment, this is the perfect place to unwind.

4. Kisenso

For something a little different, Kisenso offers the unique experience of classical music concerts during your stay, courtesy of the owner, who is a professional baritone singer. It’s a beautiful, intimate ryokan where you can relax in a private open-air bath or enjoy a seasonal kaiseki meal. For those who appreciate culture and want a blend of relaxation with a touch of class, Kisenso is a standout option.

5. Hakone Onsen Shiunso

Another top pick is Shiunso, which offers a more refined and elegant experience. Located along the peaceful Haya River, it offers breathtaking views and rooms with attached private open-air baths. The kaiseki meals served here are carefully prepared with locally sourced ingredients, making it an unforgettable experience for food lovers.

Wrapping Up: What’s Right for You?

In the end, choosing the right ryokan in Hakone really comes down to what you value most during your stay. If you're looking for a romantic escape with tranquil views and a private onsen, Tenseien or Pax Yoshino might be just what you need. If you're craving a more authentic experience, Ichinoyu Honkan offers the perfect blend of tradition and serenity. And for those who love cultural enrichment alongside their relaxation, Kisenso offers something truly unique.

No matter which ryokan you choose, our advice is to go in with realistic expectations. While some guests might love a particular place, others may have a different experience based on their personal preferences. By considering both the positive and critical feedback, you can make a well-informed decision that ensures your Hakone stay is everything you hope for—and more.

Embark on a Journey Through the Best of Hakone's Ryokans and Authentic Guest Experiences

Explore the serene beauty and rich traditions of Hakone's ryokans in 2025. SUBSCRIBE to our newsletter for FREE travel advice, hidden gems, and expert recommendations on the top ryokan experiences in Hakone. Sign up now to immerse yourself in the tranquil onsen baths, indulge in exquisite kaiseki meals, and experience the warm hospitality of Hakone’s finest ryokans!

We're here to help you plan your Japan trip based on your preferences and budget. It's free—message us at [email protected], but don't forget to subscribe! ⬇️ 

That’s it for this episode!

Thank you so much for reading today’s email! Your support is the only way I can write this email for free daily.

Kindly give us feedback in the poll below and share the newsletter with other investors if you find it valuable!